Guessing Headlights

Guessing Headlights Cars. Crime. Travel. Tech. History.

Guessing Headlights covers the unusual, the unexpected, and the stories worth sharing, from automotive adventures and roadside encounters to strange crimes, public safety, and remarkable discoveries.

A Florida woman accused of trying to hide drugs from deputies reportedly chose an interesting hiding place: underneath a...
11/09/2026

A Florida woman accused of trying to hide drugs from deputies reportedly chose an interesting hiding place: underneath a tire on a deputy's patrol car.

It probably seemed like a better idea at the time.

According to an Orange County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, deputies were patrolling the parking lot of the Monreale hotel in Orlando on November 8 when they encountered a white Mercedes SUV carrying six people.

An officer reported smelling ma*****na coming from the vehicle and ordered everyone out while deputies investigated.

That investigation turned up quite a collection of suspected drugs.

Deputies reported finding co***ne in one passenger's purse, co***ne in another passenger's boot, methamphetamine in a man's sock, and co***ne along with two small spoons on another passenger.

Then there was Nadia Nicole Guzman, 23.

Deputies say Guzman had been standing near the front driver's-side tire of a patrol car. After she was moved to another location, an officer discovered two small bags containing suspected drugs underneath that tire.

One tested presumptively positive for co***ne. The other tested presumptively positive for methamphetamine.

Investigators accused Guzman of attempting to conceal or destroy the evidence by placing the bags beneath the patrol vehicle.

Guzman was arrested on charges of co***ne possession, methamphetamine possession, drug paraphernalia possession and attempted tampering with physical evidence.

Four other passengers were also arrested on drug-related charges. The driver was not listed among those arrested in the records reviewed.

There are probably better places to hide your contraband than underneath the police car belonging to the people actively searching you.

Then again, if hiding things from the police were everyone's strong suit, we probably wouldn't have nearly as many Florida Woman stories.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Orange County Corrections

A Florida woman made a questionable choice in companions, and a $2.65 can of b**r from Wawa turned it into a criminal ca...
11/09/2026

A Florida woman made a questionable choice in companions, and a $2.65 can of b**r from Wawa turned it into a criminal case.

The b**r was returned to the store. She still ended up facing theft and drug paraphernalia charges.

According to a Volusia County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, deputies responded to a Wawa in Deltona on November 7 after Alejandro Moronta Rojas, 29, reportedly took a b**r from the cooler and walked out without paying.

When an employee confronted him, Rojas allegedly handed the b**r to Chloe Elizabeth Morgan, 24, who concealed it in her purse.

Another employee confronted Morgan, and she handed the b**r back.

That probably seemed like a reasonable place for this exceptionally stupid incident to end.

Instead, deputies located the pair nearby and arrested them. During Morgan's arrest, deputies reported finding a ma*****na grinder with residue in her purse.

So Morgan allegedly helped conceal somebody else's $2.65 b**r and wound up facing two criminal charges.

Now, about that somebody else.

Rojas is something of a frequent flyer at the Volusia County Jail. According to official booking records, he's made nine visits since November 2022.

His booking history includes cases involving DUI, fleeing police, battery, false imprisonment, witness tampering, criminal mischief, and repeated probation violations.

His April 2026 booking involved felony battery, false imprisonment, and witness tampering. Records indicate he subsequently received probation in connection with that case.

Which brings us back to the b**r.

Rojas's latest booking included a new petit theft charge and a no-bond felony probation violation connected to the earlier battery case.

Morgan was released on her own recognizance. Rojas remained in custody according to the jail records reviewed.

It's hard to imagine a much cheaper way to discover that you've been hanging around someone who makes terrible decisions.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Volusia County Corrections

A Florida woman with tattoos across her face and neck reportedly tried to convince deputies that an ID photograph showin...
11/09/2026

A Florida woman with tattoos across her face and neck reportedly tried to convince deputies that an ID photograph showing someone without said tattoos was actually hers.

Her explanation? The tattoos were only two weeks old.

The story is getting another look after Kayla Aubrey Stewart, 31, was booked into the Osceola County Jail on November 3, following her failure to appear in court on charges stemming from the February encounter.

According to an Osceola County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, deputies encountered Stewart on February 26 while investigating money missing from a driver's wallet.

A driver told deputies he'd picked up Stewart and a male passenger at a Motel 6, taken them to a smoke shop, and then dropped them off at a residence. Along the way, an unidentified man had entered his vehicle outside the shop and fled when confronted.

After dropping off his passengers, the driver discovered money missing from his wallet. He returned to the residence, where Stewart reportedly denied taking anything and blamed her male companion.

Deputies arrived to investigate and asked Stewart for identification.

She initially claimed she didn't have any ID but produced a photograph of one.

There was just one problem. Or a couple, rather.

The deputy said the woman in the photograph didn't look like Stewart, particularly because of her rather distinctive facial and neck tattoos.

Stewart reportedly explained that she'd gotten the tattoos just two weeks earlier.

The deputy wasn't buying it. He wrote that the tattoos appeared faded and that Stewart continued giving false information before eventually revealing her real name.

The investigation then took another turn. Deputies reported finding several bags of suspected methamphetamine in her belongings, including one concealed in her bra. Stewart also claimed she'd swallowed a small bag of fentanyl before deputies arrived, prompting a trip to the hospital.

Stewart was arrested on drug and false-identification charges. Court records show she subsequently failed to appear at a September 23 hearing, prompting a bench warrant that led to her November 3 arrest.

We're generally not here to judge anyone's tattoo choices. You do you.

However, if you're considering using a fake ID as part of your criminal enterprise, perhaps distinctive facial tattoos aren't the best strategic choice.

But hey, no judgment.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Osceola County Corrections

Stop me if you've heard this one before. Two dinosaurs walk into a Publix.On Halloween night in Columbus, Georgia, a cou...
11/09/2026

Stop me if you've heard this one before. Two dinosaurs walk into a Publix.

On Halloween night in Columbus, Georgia, a couple dressed in dinosaur costumes got into an argument with another customer over who was next in the checkout line.

According to the Muscogee County Sheriff's Office, Scott Harrison and Kayleigh Welch-Harrison finished checking out, but Kayleigh turned around and continued arguing with the customer.

That's when Scott pushed her aside, pulled out a gun, pointed it at the other customer, and struck the person in the neck and face with it, deputies say.

An off-duty correctional officer intervened, and the customer was treated at the scene by Columbus Fire and EMS.

Scott was arrested on five charges, including felony aggravated assault, simple battery, and reckless conduct. Kayleigh was charged with disorderly conduct.

Both dinosaurs were transported to the Muscogee County Jail.

Still, it's nice to see couples doing things together, I guess.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Muscogee County Sheriff's Office

A Florida woman reportedly figured out that one way to get her ex-boyfriend's attention was to go after his Pokémon card...
11/09/2026

A Florida woman reportedly figured out that one way to get her ex-boyfriend's attention was to go after his Pokémon cards.

Police say 23-year-old Nadia Hussain grabbed his trading cards because she knew it bothered him. After an argument, he walked her to her car and locked his apartment.

Unfortunately, she'd left her b**g behind.

She returned to collect it, allegedly forced her way inside, and headed straight back toward the Pokémon cards.

The dispute eventually involved a bathroom, an interrupted 911 call, and neighbors helping get her out of the apartment.

Hussain was arrested on domestic battery and felony witness-tampering charges.

The police report does not indicate that any Pokémon cards were harmed during the encounter.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

đź”— Full story in the comments.

Florida Woman stories can be competitive, and while this might not be a gold-medal performance, one Polk County woman ce...
11/08/2026

Florida Woman stories can be competitive, and while this might not be a gold-medal performance, one Polk County woman certainly appears to be putting in the effort.

Polk County deputies say 30-year-old Kelsey Morgan Keefe, of Sebring, was arrested October 27 after allegedly leading deputies on a pursuit in a stolen 2023 Dodge Ram 2500 flatbed truck.

The truck had been reported stolen in Georgia, but deputies located it traveling through the Davenport area of Polk County.

According to the arrest affidavit, Deputy Lawrence Zygmunt confirmed the truck was stolen and attempted a traffic stop.

The driver allegedly refused to pull over, made evasive lane changes, and continued onto westbound Interstate 4.

The pursuit ended near mile marker 54, where the Dodge Ram stopped on the shoulder.

Deputies say Keefe repeatedly refused commands to exit the vehicle, forcing them to remove her. She allegedly continued resisting as officers attempted to handcuff her.

During an inventory of the truck, deputies recovered a Ta**us G3C 9mm handgun from the driver's floorboard.

Investigators determined that the handgun had also been reported stolen.

But Keefe's recent court history adds another development to the story.

Just 31 days before this arrest, she had been released from Polk County jail.

On September 25, 2026, Keefe was convicted of felony burglary following an incident in which Haines City police said she reached through a motel service window and took a book of raffle tickets.

The court sentenced her to 24 months of probation. She was released from custody September 26.

Thirty-one days later, deputies arrested her in connection with the stolen Dodge Ram.

The October arrest also wasn't her first encounter with a motor-vehicle theft allegation.

Highlands County court records show Keefe was 18 when she was accused of grand theft of a motor vehicle in 2014.

Prosecutors declined to pursue that case, filing a formal no-bill notice on June 27, 2014. She was not convicted of that offense.

Now 30, she's facing another grand theft of a motor vehicle charge, approximately 12 years later.

Her history also includes arrests involving DUI, drug possession, vehicle registration and insurance violations, and probation-related matters.

A 2018 DUI booking identified one prior DUI conviction, although the complete outcomes of those older proceedings have not all been verified.

The latest arrest resulted in charges including grand theft of a motor vehicle, fleeing or attempting to elude police with disregard for others' safety, grand theft of a fi***rm, a fi***rm-related felony offense, and resisting officers.

The affidavit describes deputies recovering the handgun inside the truck. It does not report Keefe pointing or firing it.

Her booking also lists a probation violation and detention holds. The sheriff's record reviewed lists her as remaining in custody.

The available records do not establish who originally stole the Dodge Ram in Georgia or how Keefe obtained it.

Twelve years between motor-vehicle theft allegations, a felony burglary conviction involving raffle tickets, and a new arrest just 31 days after leaving jail.

Whether this earns her a place on the Florida Woman podium is debatable, but she's certainly built up quite a qualifying record.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Polk County Sheriff's Office

Sources: Polk County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavits and booking records; Polk County and Highlands County court records. Current case: 53-2026-CF-010699-A000-BA.

She slapped him. He slapped her back. Only one went to jail.A Halloween night at Universal Orlando ended with a domestic...
11/08/2026

She slapped him. He slapped her back. Only one went to jail.

A Halloween night at Universal Orlando ended with a domestic battery arrest after a couple's argument was captured on security cameras.

According to an Orange County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, 27-year-old Jasalay Giani Mercado, of Connecticut, was visiting Universal with her boyfriend when an argument broke out over leaving.

Mercado told deputies that paint from her Halloween costume makeup had dripped into her eyes and was hurting them. She wanted to leave, but said her boyfriend insisted they stay.

Around 12:50 a.m. on November 1, Universal security alerted deputies to a physical confrontation. Officers located the couple on Level 6 of the south parking garage as they approached their vehicle.

Mercado admitted slapping her boyfriend.

But investigators also had surveillance footage.

According to the affidavit, the video showed Mercado slapping her boyfriend across the face, followed by him slapping her back.

Neither person wanted to provide a written statement or cooperate further. Deputies reported no injuries, and both declined medical attention.

Deputy Jared Alexander determined Mercado was the primary aggressor and arrested her for misdemeanor domestic battery.

The affidavit does not indicate that her boyfriend was arrested or charged.

Both were also trespassed from Universal Studios.

Florida law directs officers investigating domestic violence to consider who was the primary aggressor, including whether someone acted in self-defense.

But that leaves an interesting question.

Is slapping someone back after they slap you self-defense, or is it retaliation?

And should we be looking at the boyfriend's booking photo, too?

What do you think? Was arresting only one person the right call?

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Orange County Corrections
Source: Orange County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, case 26-063737.

Ewww. Not the car. 🤢Can we add a charge for abuse of a vehicle's interior?According to an Orange County Sheriff's Office...
11/08/2026

Ewww. Not the car. 🤢

Can we add a charge for abuse of a vehicle's interior?

According to an Orange County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, 25-year-old Emily Siarah Meri had a rather eventful ride home from a Halloween party.

Her boyfriend told deputies she had been drinking, repeatedly tried to get out of their moving vehicle, and vomited inside the car.

He said he eventually pulled over, but Meri ran into a grassy area. After bringing her back to the vehicle, he reportedly placed her in the back seat and activated the child locks to prevent her from attempting to exit the moving car again.

Meri told deputies a different story, claiming her boyfriend tried to push her out of the vehicle and later prevented her from leaving.

But investigators found evidence supporting significant parts of his account.

Deputies inspected the vehicle and observed vomit on the passenger floorboard and the rear child locks activated.

The boyfriend's brother also provided cellphone video of a confrontation at the residence. According to the affidavit, the recording showed Meri throwing a glass vase, which shattered on the floor, before her boyfriend physically moved her toward the door.

Her boyfriend accused her of slapping him, and deputies documented scratches on his shoulder consistent with fingernails. They did not observe visible injuries to his face.

The brother also disputed Meri's claim that her boyfriend grabbed her by the neck, and deputies reported seeing no visible marks around her neck.

The boyfriend had initially called 911 to report Meri missing after she left the residence. The couple's argument continued when she returned.

After reviewing the statements, cellphone video, injuries and physical evidence, the investigating deputy concluded that the circumstances were consistent with the boyfriend's account and identified Meri as the primary aggressor.

Meri was arrested November 1 on a misdemeanor dating-violence battery charge. Neither party wanted to pursue criminal charges, but the deputy proceeded with the arrest.

As for the vehicle's interior, no criminal charges for upholstery abuse appear in the affidavit. The carpet, unfortunately, had no say in the matter.

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

📸 Orange County Corrections
Source: Orange County Sheriff's Office arrest affidavit, case 26-063774.

11/08/2026

Florida troopers are looking for a DoorDash driver who reportedly hit a marked Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission patrol truck parked in a driveway.

According to FHP, the driver was delivering food in a dark-colored SUV in Citrus Springs on October 28 when the vehicle struck the FWC Ford F-150.

The driver then completed the delivery and left without notifying anyone.

Apparently, the food was still getting delivered.

Home surveillance footage captured the driver and SUV, although the collision itself isn't shown.

FHP is asking anyone who recognizes the driver to call *347 or Crime Stoppers at **TIPS.

📹 Florida Highway Patrol

Sometimes the best thing you can do during a traffic stop is just sit there and be quiet.One Florida woman discovered th...
11/07/2026

Sometimes the best thing you can do during a traffic stop is just sit there and be quiet.

One Florida woman discovered that's easier said than done, and the resulting self-own is, well, classic Florida Woman.

On November 2, a Marion County deputy pulled over a Toyota in Ocala because it had a headlight out.

Before he even approached the vehicle, he watched the driver switch seats with a passenger. Turns out, the original driver had a suspended license.

Already off to a fantastic start.

But 33-year-old Amber Marie Fisher, who was riding in the front passenger seat, apparently decided this situation needed a little more excitement.

According to the arrest affidavit, Fisher started yelling at the deputy, repeatedly got out of the car despite being told to stay inside, and refused to follow his instructions.

Eventually, the deputy put her in handcuffs and told her to sit on the push bumper of his patrol car.

She reportedly refused that, too.

So she ended up in the back of the patrol car.

Remember, this whole thing started over a broken headlight. On a car she wasn't even driving.

Fisher was arrested and charged with resisting an officer without violence. Her bond was set at $1,000.

Some people talk themselves out of tickets. Others manage to talk themselves into an entirely new criminal case.

📸 Marion County Sheriff's Office

All parties are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

Address

Beavercreek, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Guessing Headlights posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share