23/01/2016
Jan 23 2016 : The Times of India (Mumbai)
GO `PRO'
The Apple iPad Pro and Microsoft's Surface Pro 4 have a lot in common. Both sport the tablet form factor; come with detachable keyboards and baked-in stylus support. Drawing comparisons between these two is therefore inevitable.
Savio D'Souza reviews both devices that have seemingly blurred the lines between the tablet and the PC
THE DESIGN TEST
To test the stylus support on the iPad Pro and the Surface Pro 4, we asked our in-house illustrators and 3D artists to try the tablets. Mahesh Benkar, whose free but sure pen strokes define his illustrations took to both devices instinctively.Within the first 10 minutes on the iPad Pro, he sketched an aging couple out on their evening walk using the Adobe Sketch app and the Apple Pencil. After a few other quickly scribbled caricatures on the iPad Pro, Benkar was satisfied with how responsive the Pencil was to pressure, and how tilting it on the screen gave him broader strokes. “It's almost like sketching with a real pencil,“ he said. “Almost.“
Bhagvan Das, whose favourite software is Adobe Illustrator, was quite pleased by the responsiveness of the Pen on the Surface Pro.It took him around 20 minutes to get accustomed to the Fresh Paint app that came on the tablet and to paint an ascetic in a style that mimicked acrylic colours, pen and pencil on canvas. “This is superb“ is what he kept saying to himself as he `painted'. 3D artist and avid Photoshopper Ram also tried out different software and apps on both devices. Ram has recently picked up a Wacom 13HD Touch for around `70k. “It would be unfair to compare the fantastic stylus response of a Wacom with either of these devices,“ he said, “but these two tablets work very well with large graphic files, and most importantly, they give you portability, allowing you to design and sketch anywhere.“
All three artists agreed that the Surface Pro “felt softer to sketch on“, when compared to the more glassy, harder display of the iPad Pro, but didn't think that this factor was a deal breaker against the latter.
“I like the iPad's larger screen,“ Benkar said.“It gave me room for expansive strokes.“
“Both these devices are ideal for designers, cartoonists and sketch artists, where these is more inking and less shading,“ Ram averred.
Bhagvan liked that you could install desktop software on the Surface Pro. “Superb,“ he muttered for the nth time before he went back to his digital painting
WHERE THE IPAD PRO COMES OUT TOPS
Thinner, Lighter, Larger Screen: The iPad Pro has a larger 12.9inch (2732x2048px) screen (all of which can be used for app display), and it's just 6.9mm thin at the edge, tilting the scales at 712g. In comparison, the Surface Pro is equipped with a 12.3-inch (max resolution of 2736x1824px) screen (some of which might be taken up by the Start taskbar). It is 8.4mm thin and weighs in 786g.
The iPad boasts of a slightly better display overall, but the difference is negligible and borders on absolute nit picking. Buildwise, both devices are crafted beautifully: the iPad boasts of an aluminium unibody , while the Surface Pro uses a strong magnesium casing.
4G SIM: With the iPad Pro, you have the option of a “Wi-Fi + Cellular“ model. This means you get internet connectivity on the move via a SIM slot that supports 4G speeds. With the Surface, you will need to find or create a Wi-Fi hotspot.
Apps and Games: iOS is known for its superb mix of productivity apps, utilities, entertainment and educational content. In fact, there's a complete section on the App Store dedicated to apps for the iPad Pro and the Apple Pencil. Here, you can find sketching, design and painting apps from names like Adobe and Autodesk, musicand movie-editing tools, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, as well as productivity apps from other vendors. Also, when it comes to gaming, you can expect to download some great casual and 3D games, and this also gives it a definite edge over the Microsoft tablet.
Speakers: The Surface Pro comes with Dolby stereo speakers, and are capable of fairly loud audio playback, without loss in quality even at high volumes. But when pitted against the iPad's four speakers (two at the top and two at the bottom), these dual speakers seem to be at a clear disadvantage. All of the iPad Pro's speakers are capable of bass output and this makes a huge difference. The device automatically recognizes the orientation of the tablet to serve you mid and high frequencies from the top speakers and bass from the bottom for a loud, fuller sound.
Camera: The Surface Pro has a 5MP front camera, while the iPad Pro has a 1.2MP shooter. But despite the lower resolution, the capture from the iPad was on a par with the Surface Pro during video calls.
When it comes to the rear shooters, the iPad's 8MP cam is a winner over the Surface Pro's 8MP , with clearer and brighter photographs.
Battery: We got around six hours on the Surface Pro on a single charge, whereas the iPad Pro lasted nine and a half hours. These tests were conducted over a few days and the battery life was more or less consistent during that period.
WHERE THE SURFACE PRO 4 SCORES
Kickstand and Keyboard: The Surface Pro comes with its own kickstand. The iPad Pro requires its keyboard to be attached to prop it up. And this brings us to the keyboards... The iPad Pro's 64-key keyboard is just 4mm thin, as well as water and stain resistant. It attaches to the tablet firmly via Apple's new Smart Connector interface and is beautifully balanced, allowing you to type with the device in your lap without the fear of it keeling over. But here, Microsoft's 78-key Surface Pro 4 Type cover has the clear edge. What you get is a touchpad, and a responsive backlit keys, complete with the tactile feel that makes for comfortable typing. Both keyboards, double up as covers for the tablets when not in use.
Stylus: While the iPad Pro's Pencil detects various degrees of pressure, as well as tilt of the nib on the screen for wider strokes, the Surface Pro's Pen scores over it on myriad counts. Unlike the Apple Pencil, which gives you around 10 hours on a single charge, the Microsoft Pen is powered by a single AAAA battery that's rated to last for almost a year. The stylus also has a button on its body that functions as rightclick in Windows. You can also turn the Pen around and use its head as an eraser on the tablet's screen. And yes, the Pen is magnetic so it sticks to the tablet letting you keep it within reach at all times. That said, both styluses work wonderfully with their respective devices.
Software: The Surface Pro might not have an app ecosystem that's as extensive as the iPad Pro's, but whatever software you run on your PC, whether Photoshop, InDesign, Illustrator, 3ds Max, you can run it on this tablet.
Storage: The iPad Pro comes with 32GB and 128GB solid state drives, whereas the Surface Pro comes with 128GB and 256GB SSDs. Also, the Surface has a USB port and a microSD card slot, and this makes transferring files to and from the device extremely easy.
Of course, you can also connect a printer, camera, or your phone via the USB port so that's another plus. Multi-tasking and Performance: The iPad Pro cannot shoot 4K videos, but it can handle the simultaneous editing of multiple such ultra hi-res clips in its iMovie app this by itself is a fair indicator of the kind of processing muscle under its hood. The Apple device also lets you work with two apps side-by-side (when using native apps such as Videos, Safari, Podcasts or even Adobe tools, simply swipe-in from the right edge of your screen, and you are provided with a list of compatible apps that can be run simultaneously in a split screen). It should be noted that the number of apps that support this feature is limited. And finally , the iPad supports picture-in-picture that lets you view videos in a small window while continuing to work in another app.
In our review, we tested the Core i5 version of the Surface Pro with 4GB RAM, and again, this tablet was up to the challenge, handling hi-resolution photo-editing tasks in Photoshop. And since this tablet runs Windows 10, it also supports multiple desktops and software for seamless and stutter-free multi-tasking.
CONCLUSION:
The Apple iPad Pro is the tablet to buy for its ease of use, fantastic apps, games, music tools, and hassle-free working. With its large screen, stylus support and keyboard, it now makes inroads into productivity territory, allowing you to type documents, work on spreadsheets, presentations and even on design and sketches. Besides, its light weight and support for 4G SIMs make it a truly portable device.
On the other hand, the Surface Pro 4 is a full-fledged PC that comes with the additional functionality of a stylus, allowing you to use it as a no-holds-barred tablet when desired. It boasts of powerful hardware, and could well be the upgrade you were looking for in laptops.