08/26/2026
I’m going to rant about this **Medicare for All** thing one time.
I understand why it sounds good on the surface. Everybody gets healthcare. Everybody gets access to doctors and hospitals. Nobody goes without treatment because they can’t afford insurance. Wonderful idea when you put it in one sentence.
But there are some questions nobody seems to want to talk about.
First, giving every person unlimited access to the same healthcare system does not magically create more doctors, nurses, specialists, hospital beds, operating rooms, or appointments. You can increase the number of people entitled to care overnight. You cannot increase the capacity of the medical system overnight. Somebody is going to wait.
But that isn’t even the part that bothers me the most.
**I have paid Medicare taxes out of virtually every paycheck I have earned since I was 16 years old.**
Hour after hour. Year after year. Decade after decade.
That money wasn’t optional. It came out of my earnings because Medicare was presented as something working Americans paid into throughout their lives so that the program would be there when they reached the age to use it.
Now I keep hearing that Medicare should simply become Medicare for everybody, regardless of whether someone has paid into that system for 40 or 50 years, five years, or not one day in their life.
Okay.
Then answer one question for me:
**What happened to the value of everything I spent my entire working life paying into?**
If we decide as a country that healthcare is going to be a universal government benefit available equally to everyone simply because they live here, then fine. Have that debate.
But don't simultaneously tell someone who has paid Medicare taxes for nearly half a century that those contributions somehow don't matter anymore.
If we're wiping the slate clean and everybody starts from exactly the same place, then let's really wipe the slate clean.
Either credit or refund the people who spent decades paying into the old system, or create some meaningful distinction between benefits earned through decades of contributions and benefits provided universally.
What I object to is this idea that we can completely change what the program *is* while pretending that the trillions of dollars working Americans have already paid into it somehow never existed.
You cannot have it both ways.
And before somebody tells me, “Healthcare is a right,” understand that this isn’t an argument about whether I want somebody who is sick to receive medical care.
**Of course I do.**
It is an argument about fairness.
If America wants to create universal healthcare, then call it universal healthcare, figure out honestly how we're going to pay for it, figure out honestly how we're going to provide enough healthcare professionals to serve everybody, and build a system specifically for that purpose.
But don't take a program that millions of Americans spent their entire working lives funding, dramatically change the bargain after the fact, and then tell those people there is nothing to discuss.
There damn well is.