11/13/2026
Before you publish 10,000 programmatic SEO pages, write the rule for when you’ll delete them.
That might be the most important part of Nitin Manchanda’s pSEO checklist. Because publishing at scale is no longer difficult.
AI has made it incredibly easy to generate thousands of pages, convince yourself you have a “programmatic SEO strategy,” and get them live before anyone has properly asked:
Does each of these pages actually deserve to exist?
Nitin has been building programmatic SEO systems since 2016, and there’s an important distinction in his latest article for SEJ:
Programmatic SEO and mass AI publishing are not the same thing.
Real pSEO starts with a structured dataset. The template scales access to that data across thousands of useful variations. Mass AI publishing keeps the template and replaces the dataset with a prompt.
But if the underlying information hasn’t changed, what new value did you actually create? And that’s increasingly the line that matters.
Google doesn’t have a policy against “programmatic SEO.” It has a policy against scaled content abuse. Automation isn’t the problem. Scale isn’t the problem. AI isn’t even necessarily the problem.
Scaling pages that don’t add anything useful is the problem.
Nitin’s process puts some much-needed friction back into publishing:
→ Identify the unique data source before building anything. If you can’t name it, question whether you really have a pSEO opportunity.
→ Define the minimum amount of data required before a page is allowed to exist, then enforce that rule in code.
→ Publish 25–50 pages first. Test indexation and quality before pushing thousands live.
→ Review the pages again whenever the template changes. One seemingly small edit can affect an entire section of the site.
→ And crucially: write the kill rule before launch.
The lesson isn’t “don’t do programmatic SEO.” It’s: Scale the value, not just the page count.
Nitin’s full article on Search Engine Journal includes a very practical framework for deciding what to publish, test, measure, refresh, and, importantly, remove.
Link in the comments.