Collecting Haven

Collecting Haven Collecting Haven is the perfect place for collectors to gather! We offer a variety of sports memorab

Few light & heavy Fossil packs and a small collection of video games!Reminder, we are accepting PSA submissions until th...
11/02/2026

Few light & heavy Fossil packs and a small collection of video games!

Reminder, we are accepting PSA submissions until this Sunday (scroll back a few post for those details).

Congrats to Chris S. & James V. for being our weekly gift card winners! 👏

Happy Sunday!! ☀️30th anniversary Pokémon drawing results: This is the smallest allocations we’ve received of 30th items...
11/01/2026

Happy Sunday!! ☀️

30th anniversary Pokémon drawing results:

This is the smallest allocations we’ve received of 30th items, so if we receive more we will draw more names. Thank you for everyone that stopped into enter!

Below you will find a list of names (if your name is on this list you have the opportunity to purchase that item).

Pick up will be available starting at 10am Friday and you will have until 6pm Monday evening to pick up. Items that are not claimed by 6pm Monday will be released, and a new name will be drawn. If you are going to pass, no worries! Just give us a heads up so we can draw another name.

Price points-we will post prices Thursday evening as we want to offer the most accurate prices (80% of market price will be approximate prices).

UPC boxes will have 2 different price points (day & night version). If you were chosen for UPC, versions will be first picked up get first picks.

As always, sorry for any misspelling of names!

Ultra Premium Collection
1. Kongmeng Xiong
2. Dan Knaack
3. Brandon Lee
4. Kaitlin Kramarczyk
5. Tristian Thao
6. Kevin Thao
7. Brian Leigh
8. Allie Riedl
9. Trevor Wentzel
10. Aaron Johnson
11. Brandon Ertl
12. Ty Lotten
13. Seth Robertson
14. Jeremy Theunis

Figure Collection box
1. Dayton Bee
2. Hannah Reinboldt
3. Felicia Schmidt
4. Adam Delfoose
5. Marissa Everson
6. Kyle Woolger

Ditto box
1. Dan Vlach
2. Morgan Wietphal
3. Drew Kong
4. Aaron Schafer
5. Erin Blajeski
6. Mike Junek

Happy Halloween! 🎃 We have packs of cards and candy for kiddos dressed in costume from 9am to 4pm today!We have some sin...
10/31/2026

Happy Halloween! 🎃

We have packs of cards and candy for kiddos dressed in costume from 9am to 4pm today!

We have some singles and slabs hitting the display cases.

Looking to send cards off to grading? Look back a few post for more details!

And finally, final reminder for our next 30th anniversary drawing for opportunity to purchase ends today (results will be posted on Sunday)!

Another UPS order arrived today:30th ETB & EX boxes (will have limits)2026 Donruss NFL Hobby25-26 NHL Stature hobby My L...
10/30/2026

Another UPS order arrived today:

30th ETB & EX boxes (will have limits)

2026 Donruss NFL Hobby

25-26 NHL Stature hobby

My Little Pony volume 4 booster boxes

See you until 8pm!

Few new items that arrived this week:2026 Optic NWSL hobby boxes2026-27 Upper Deck Series 1 tins & blastersRiftbound Vau...
10/30/2026

Few new items that arrived this week:

2026 Optic NWSL hobby boxes

2026-27 Upper Deck Series 1 tins & blasters

Riftbound Vault boxes

Pokémon 30th Deck Crafter collection (these have 1 pack in them)

Pokémon 30th Battle Deck (no packs but some great promos)

We also have some 30th etbs & ex boxes from distribution on way next week.

Congrats to Jordan C & Corrie H for being our weekly gift card winners! 👏

See you from 10-8!

New cheaper service available! PSA submission details:Deadline is Sunday November 8th at 2pm.Value level, $46 per card v...
10/29/2026

New cheaper service available!

PSA submission details:

Deadline is Sunday November 8th at 2pm.

Value level, $46 per card values up to $500 with turn around times of 90-100 business days (4.5-5 months)

We just sent out at higher levels so at this time only sending out value level.

In a month or so we will offer all levels available.

If you have a question about a cards conditions or value swing by we will take a look.

We will be open from 4pm to 6pm tomorrow (Thursday) and back to normal hours starting Friday! 🙌 We will have a bunch of ...
10/29/2026

We will be open from 4pm to 6pm tomorrow (Thursday) and back to normal hours starting Friday! 🙌

We will have a bunch of new products that arrived while we were away so that stuff will be hitting the shelves asap. We will post photos of everything Friday morning.

PSA just announced the opening of the $40 level (our price will be $46 per card) and we will start accepting cards Friday morning until the following Friday. We will also make a seperate post laying out all details.

Halloween is Saturday! Even though most trick or treating starts after we close for the day, we will have Halloween Pokémon BOOster packs to hand out to kiddos who’d like to stop by in their costumes!

Finally, a few slabs and video games that were traded in right before we left on vacation. These are available now!

10/28/2026

Hey everyone! We are posting this as an awareness in our community that there are unfortunately thieves out there. 😞

This happened in Oshkosh and Fond du lac, and thought we know it’s a bit away from us it’s still close enough.

We put every ounce of our energy and dollar into our small business. The shop provides for my family and I also strive to create a fun and welcoming environment.

We don’t hide the fact that we do have cameras in our store and footage is watched/reviewed as needed on a regular basis, including multiple cameras in our parking lot.

Please, please think before acting as we will not tolerate stealing. All of us local card shop owners in the area communicate with each other and look out for each other, If something happens at a particular shop, we all get a heads up pretty quickly.

We don’t like making posts like this, and we know it’s typically one or two people who spoil it for the rest, but we’re crossing our fingers that it stops with these couple individuals. 🤞

Last posted reminder for the 30th anniversary Pokémon drawing. You have until 4pm today. Otherwise, you can enter this w...
10/24/2026

Last posted reminder for the 30th anniversary Pokémon drawing. You have until 4pm today. Otherwise, you can enter this week from 4pm to 6pm on Thursday, or Friday and Saturday.

Some singles are hitting the display cases; full art and trainer/energy binders got a minor restock also.

If we dont see ya today, see you starting 4pm Thursday!

Riftbound Radiance booster boxes will be available at 10am Friday! We have some value boxes on the way as well, but they...
10/22/2026

Riftbound Radiance booster boxes will be available at 10am Friday! We have some value boxes on the way as well, but they won’t arrive until next week.

Speaking of next week, we will be closed this upcoming Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and will be back open Thursday from 4pm to 6pm!

Address

N474 Eisenhower Drive Suite J
Appleton, WI
54915

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm
Sunday 9am - 2pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Collecting Haven posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby computer & electronics services